February 20, 2008

Monopoly alert: Spread the word

While attending Toyfair, I found out that Hasbro is putting together an international version of Monopoly, and instead of street names on the board, there will be city names. The color coding remains the same: The most valuable real estate will be on blue spots, for instance (normally occupied by Broadway and Park Place), and then green, yellow and so on. There is currently a vote going on that is open to anyone in the world with a computer, and you can vote once a day for up to ten cities. The top vote getters will be on Broadway and Park Place, and the rest will be apportioned to the remainder of the real estate.

Now how, you may ask, is the United States faring in this international voting? The answer: Miserably. Of the twenty eight properties on this quintessentially American game, only two US cities are making any kind of showing, and neither is in prime real estate. New York is #8 (relegated to the much less tony yellow section of the board), while, Las Vegas is an abysmal #23. What's number one, you may ask? The most popular international city?

Istanbul.

Are you freaking kidding me?

Personally, I think this is an abysmal state of affairs. Istanbul the number one city of international Monopoly? The best thing one can say about Istanbul is that it's a catchy song covered by "They Might Be Giants." But "New York, New York" is practically an anthem.

According to the woman at Hasbro I spoke to, the website where the voting is going on--www.monopoly.com--is getting 10,000 votes a day. That's not all that much. A concerted web effort can turn this around.

Obviously I want to see New York nestled in the top spot, with more US cities occupying as many of the rest of the valuable properties as possible. Knee-jerk patriotism? Unreasonable nationalism? Well...yeah. You got a problem with that? If the residents of freaking Turkey should be allowed that indulgence, so should I.

We've only got until February 28th to get it done, so spread the word to all and sundry. Feel free to repost this anywhere and everywhere.

PAD

Posted by Peter David at February 20, 2008 11:16 AM | TrackBack | Other blogs commenting
Comments
Posted by: Sig at February 20, 2008 11:57 AM

Turkey's all about concerted web efforts, all the way back to the Time magazine people of the century contest. The words of Kent Brockman are even more resonant when applied to the Internet: "I've said it before and I'll say it again, democracy just doesn't work."

Posted by: Peter David at February 20, 2008 12:06 PM

Yeah, well, there's 70 million of them and 300 million of us. If it comes to sheer concerted effort, we should be able to swing this.

PAD

Posted by: Jonathan (the other one) at February 20, 2008 12:12 PM

And don't forget the nomination process, too. For some reason, Hasbro only has five American cities on their list (and they don't even include Seattle, home to Hasbro subsidiary Wizards of the Coast!).

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 20, 2008 12:38 PM

All we need to do is get Stephan Colbert to mention this on his show. New York would be #1 the next day.

Posted by: Auryn at February 20, 2008 12:57 PM

Not Constantinople? Huh.

Posted by: Eric at February 20, 2008 01:12 PM

Or we can subvert it, using the Wildcard vote. All vote for the worst possible answer. Like Tehran or something. Or Love Canal.

Maybe we can all pick a fictional city, Like Gotham City, and write it in. Or we could make upa name, like Dildo, PA and vote it in.

Posted by: BrianOsserman at February 20, 2008 01:20 PM

Lets see if Hasbro has any real balls. Get every one to vote for Israel! See how well it sells in IRAN if the Jews get Park Place. ;-)

Posted by: Scavenger at February 20, 2008 01:21 PM

Jonathon...what more 5 cities should be listed as international for the US? Frankly I don't think DC, Chicago, or Boston belong on there. Even Vegas is dodgey...is it really an international attraction? New Orleans should be there, though.

Posted by: Scavenger at February 20, 2008 01:24 PM

Brian. Israel is a country, not a city.

Jerusalem is @ #4

And do you really think Iranians buy Monopoly?

Posted by: Somebody at February 20, 2008 01:33 PM

*votes for 10 cities, none of which are in the US :D*

Posted by: Tim Lynch at February 20, 2008 01:47 PM

I like the fictional city idea, but I'd be careful of a suggestion like Dildo, PA -- I mean, we're talking a state here that already has Intercourse and Climax, not to be confused with Accident...

TWL
too late to make the "not Constantinople" joke

Posted by: Queen Anthai at February 20, 2008 02:07 PM

New Orleans should be there, though.

Yes, please.

Posted by: Gordy Toler at February 20, 2008 02:07 PM

Well I don't know about you people, but I voted for Istanbul too (based entirely on the fact that I love They Might Be Giants, and their song about New York City isn't nearly as catchy).

Posted by: Robert Fuller at February 20, 2008 02:24 PM

I hate New York, so there's no way I'll vote for it (although I disagree that the TMBG song about it is less catchy than "Istanbul (Not Constantinople)"). If anything, I'd say Dubai deserves the Boardwalk spot.

Posted by: Tim Lynch at February 20, 2008 02:29 PM

Jonathon...what more 5 cities should be listed as international for the US? Frankly I don't think DC, Chicago, or Boston belong on there.

DC has so much international-themed stuff in it that I think it would be at least worthy of consideration. I agree about Boston and Chicago, though.

Even Vegas is dodgey...is it really an international attraction?

Based on the hordes of tourists I saw the last time I was there ... yes.

New Orleans should be there, though.

As a sympathy vote, absolutely. In terms of its international significance ... I'm not sure, honestly.

TWL

Posted by: lorinheller at February 20, 2008 03:16 PM

Hey! I like Chicago! (sniff sniff).

Posted by: Nat Gertler at February 20, 2008 03:19 PM

So you really want us to vote to raise the New York City rents?

Posted by: Peter David at February 20, 2008 03:25 PM

Cripes, this is like trying to herd cats. No wonder Istanbul is where it is: Everyone there is focused. Everyone here is all over the place. Could we get our heads in the game, people?

And yeah, if Colbert got on board, it would be a lock, presuming that the show is new next week.

PAD

Posted by: Andrew Laubacher at February 20, 2008 03:41 PM

Here is a link to the page that the Hasbro homepage directs you to:

http://hasbro.com/games/kid-games/monopoly/

Posted by: kkozoriz at February 20, 2008 03:54 PM

There's already a Dildo but it's in Newfoundland as opposed to the American one that's in the White House.

http://maps.google.ca/maps?f=q&hl=en&geocode=&q=dildo,+nl&ie=UTF8&ll=47.562627,-53.548737&spn=0.180702,0.372849&z=12

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 20, 2008 04:00 PM

I vote Richmond!!!!!

~8?)

Posted by: Derek at February 20, 2008 04:00 PM

Sorry, PAD, but as a dutiful Canadian I'd rather push for Ottawa or Toronto.

Unfortunately, this is the way democracy works. The US makes up about 4.6% of the world's population and hasn't done much to endear itself to the other 95.6% - especially these last few years under Bush's leadership.

Anyway, you can content yourselves that all the streets in the original are from an American city.

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 20, 2008 04:10 PM

Well, you get to vote for 10 cities, Derek. And you can vote again every day. Tell you what, you add New York to the cities you vote for and I'll add Ottawa and Toronto to the cities I vote for. Then we'll have multinational cooperation among this thread, at least.

Posted by: Tim Lynch at February 20, 2008 04:20 PM

Derek, that's 100.2%. I'm just sayin'. :-)

TWL

"But he is one and you are three."
"RRRRR."
"Or four if you count him twice."

Posted by: JamesLynch at February 20, 2008 04:26 PM

I vote Arkham, MA. (Take that, Innsmouth!)

Posted by: Peter David at February 20, 2008 04:37 PM

Well, you get to vote for 10 cities, Derek.

Thank God SOMEbody is paying attention. With people saying, "I vote for this city" or "I vote for that city," I was unsure what part of "You can vote for up to ten cities every day" was unclear.

PAD

Posted by: Peter David at February 20, 2008 05:10 PM

If anyone wants to go crosspost this to the colbernation website, they should feel free to do so.

For that matter, I'd be interested to know anyplace else that people actually put up links to this.

PAD

Posted by: James at February 20, 2008 05:22 PM

Oh just wait until the Japanese, Korean, and Chinese netizens get their hands on this one. I would be willing to bet that Seoul ends up in one of those two spots.

Posted by: Tom Galloway at February 20, 2008 05:44 PM

How the heck did Cardiff get on the list? Torchwood fan at Hasbro or something?

Me, I'm voting for Springfield. Take that, Shelbyville!

Posted by: foonon at February 20, 2008 05:52 PM

I've put up a post in the "Colbert Report" forum, following up to a previous post from last month.

I expressed my rage by shouting at the monitor while typing.

~f

Posted by: foonon at February 20, 2008 05:54 PM

> I've put up a post in the "Colbert Report" forum, following up to a previous post from last month.

At the ColbertNation.com site, of course!

~f

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 20, 2008 05:55 PM

"I expressed my rage by shouting at the monitor while typing."

While driving.

Posted by: J Burgess at February 20, 2008 06:06 PM

I voted. Not that they made it easy. I hate places that want my e-mail for stuff like this. I know I'm going to get spammed for this. And after I went through the trouble it took 4 tiems before it would recognize my vote. >blechI voted. Not that they made it easy. I hate places that want my e-mail for stuff like this. I know I'm going to get spammed for this. And after I went through the trouble it took 4 tiems before it would recognize my vote. >blech

Voted for New York, Las Vegas, Chicago, London, Madrid, Jerusalem, Tokyo, Montreal, Toronto, Paris

Posted by: Jocelyn at February 20, 2008 06:07 PM

I was appalled, as a Canadian, to see that Toronto wasn't in the top 20, although pleased Vancouver & Montreal were! I voted for all three, as well as New York, Paris, Vienna, Rome, Rio, Sydney & London. I will continue to vote for New York if you guys help by voting for Toronto! I didn't see Ottawa on the list, and frankly, I think Toronto deserves it more, even if Ottawa is our country's capital.

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 20, 2008 06:20 PM

"I hate places that want my e-mail for stuff like this."

I have a hotmail account just for stuff like this. The amount of spam it gets is hilarious, but my real account barely gets spam at all.

Posted by: Pat Nolan at February 20, 2008 06:57 PM

Posted by BrianOsserman at February 20, 2008 01:20 PM
Lets see if Hasbro has any real balls. Get every one to vote for Israel! See how well it sells in IRAN if the Jews get Park Place. ;-)

dude the Jews already have Park Place....
(typed in perfect Don Rickles repartay)

I vote for...
10. LA
9. New York
8. Seattle
7. Minneapolis
6. New Orleans
5. San Francisco
4. Chicago
3. DC
2. Dublin, Ireland (cause Im Irish)
1. San Diego

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 20, 2008 07:11 PM

For that matter, I'd be interested to know anyplace else that people actually put up links to this.

PAD


Well PAD, other then being a smartass and posting my Richmond bit, I've thrown it up on my site (for those extra three people who read mine that don't come here) and did a copy and paste of your post into an email that I sent out a while ago.

That's something that anybody else who actually wants to spread this news around should do. Far more people that you know will likely see it that way and they'll maybe forward it out to the people on their contacts list.

Can't hurt.

Posted by: El Hombre Malo at February 20, 2008 07:50 PM

Madrid and Barcelona are in the list (or were a few days ago) and the whole thing was covered (if briefly) in spanish media a week or so ago.

Istanbul is a great choice for top city... If Asimov could wrote a whole book about its history, I am pretty sure it deserves consideration. I am voting for New York for sure, but I dont really think any other american city deserves to be placed over places historically and culturally richer. I am pretty sure the USA will get at least two cities anyway.

Posted by: Alan Wilkinson at February 20, 2008 07:53 PM

Just leave room for London, please.

Posted by: Scavenger at February 20, 2008 07:55 PM

I posted a link here over at Comics Should Be Good at CBR.cc

Posted by: Bill Mulligan at February 20, 2008 09:27 PM

I say that any city deemed worthy of attack by the Kilaaks in 1999, using the monsters from Monsterland, is worthy of inclusion. That would be New York (attacked by Godzilla), Moscow (Rodan), Beijing (Mothra), Paris (Baragon or Gorosaurus, depending on who's counting), and London (Manda).

Posted by: Mike at February 20, 2008 10:32 PM

The Prince mentioned how the dictator-like control of the Ottoman Empire was tougher to overthrow than the European principalities. It might still be cool to have a "Monopoly: Machiavelli Edition."

Posted by: Alan Coil at February 20, 2008 10:48 PM

This is an outrage. New York ought to be in the Boardwalk space. Los Angeles and Chicago should get prime spots, too, all on the last side. London could be where Kentucky is.

And as a poke at Turkey, Istanbul should be the first corner after Go. The jail corner, 'cause we all know you can't get out of jail free in Turkey.

Posted by: Peter David at February 20, 2008 11:54 PM

And as a poke at Turkey, Istanbul should be the first corner after Go. The jail corner, 'cause we all know you can't get out of jail free in Turkey.

Ohhhhhh! Coil shoots...he scores!

PAD

Posted by: Alex Jay Berman at February 21, 2008 01:47 AM

I think Philadelphia belongs on the wildcard list--if not, I'll be stuck voting for Novi Sad because it's the birthplace of a great friend of mine.
(Gydania, Poland is the most-nominated city? Are you kidding me?)

Posted by: Peter Svensson at February 21, 2008 05:07 AM

Posted it at RPG.Net's Tangency forums, so we'll see how international gaming geeks respond. I'm definitely voting now.

Posted by: Bladestar at February 21, 2008 06:32 AM

For "Jail" they should use "Detroit, MI"

Posted by: TadPrime at February 21, 2008 08:31 AM

Thanks for the heads up, hopefully we can turn it around. Although the initial city selection is a little odd; how can Lyon be on there but San Francisco isn't?

Posted by: Hypersonic at February 21, 2008 10:19 AM

Hmmm. I always though that Monopoly was a quintissentially British game.

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 21, 2008 10:39 AM

How so?

Posted by: Peter David at February 21, 2008 11:36 AM

Yeah, I'm not following that claim either. It was invented in America and first produced in America. There was a British edition, much as there have been editions in other countries, but America was first.

All the more aggravating to see us being given short shrift.

PAD

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 21, 2008 11:39 AM

I have the British edition! My sister spent a year in England a long time ago and brought it back for me. I might have actually bought Trafalgar Square more times in my life than Boardwalk.

Posted by: El hombre Malo at February 21, 2008 12:05 PM

There was a monopoly version in my country during the 80's (either a ripoff or a licensed version, I dont know) called "Treasure's route" (La Ruta del Tesoro).

Instead of street names you had ports of the mediterraneum, instead of hotels you built forts and the currency came in the form of bronze, silver and gold coins, in diferent shapes and sizes, plus scrolls representing the biggest form of currency.

And the most expensive port in the mediterraneum...?

Instanbul, of course

Posted by: Lester Carthan at February 21, 2008 01:42 PM

Given the fact that this is the International version of the game I kind of like the fact that other cites around the globe take precedence over New York and America in general.

Posted by: Paul1963 at February 21, 2008 02:45 PM

Man, getting that site to take my vote was a pain in the ass. Now that I've registered I'll throw a few votes to NYC (which was number 8 on the leaderboard a few minutes ago).

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 21, 2008 04:59 PM

"And as a poke at Turkey, Istanbul should be the first corner after Go. The jail corner, 'cause we all know you can't get out of jail free in Turkey."

Midnight Express!!! I tip my hat to you, sir. I'm kicking myself that I didn't think of that one myself.

Great movie. Great tag team. ~8?)

Posted by: Alexa at February 21, 2008 06:01 PM

Fuck! Someone alert Stephen Colbert! He got a bridge in Hungary named after him, he can get American cities on Boardwalk and Park Place.

Posted by: El hombre Malo at February 21, 2008 07:39 PM

seriously... do you think more than two american cities deserve to be represented in the game over other places in the world? or you simply dont care if they do and want them to be there anyway?

Posted by: Bruholland at February 21, 2008 07:53 PM

This post really reeks of bad nationalism. So what if Monopoly is American-made. It's worldwide now and other countries seem to like it more. If New York isn't #1, it's because enough people don't care about it. THAT'S JUST HOW THINGS ARE.

Posted by: Hypersonic at February 21, 2008 09:46 PM

I was being ironic...sorry.

I played it insesssently as a boy, my friends and I often had championships where games could last for days.

Here in Brazil it's called "BAnco Imobiliario" = Real Estate Bank.

Posted by: Alan Coil at February 21, 2008 10:33 PM

Bruholland, I'm so sorry.

Posted by: Carl at February 21, 2008 10:58 PM

Having been to Istanbul, all I can say is "Mediterranean."

Posted by: Nick Eden at February 22, 2008 03:29 AM

Istanbul's a great place, well worth a visit. I have seen the dagger and beard clippings of the Prophet, who could ask for more?

But I can't work myself up to be excited by all these 'there's a new edition of Monopoly' stories the media are running. FFS, there are hundreds of different Monopoly boards, with new ones coming out each week. Kudos to Hasbro for making a story out of it, but it's stopped being news.

Posted by: bobb alfred at February 22, 2008 08:34 AM

I've been voting the past two days. Perhaps Hasbro hasn't been advertising this as well as they could have? What good is it going to do them if the voting produces skewed results? It won't be a good product, and it won't sell.

Then again, it's an opoly game. The presence of so many of them tells me that people are like lemmings when it comes to them.

Posted by: Jocelyn at February 22, 2008 09:02 AM

They took the leaderboard away! Now we can't even see how our cities are doing...but I continue to vote anyway...

Posted by: Peter David at February 22, 2008 09:10 AM

This post really reeks of bad nationalism.

Well, gee...you really got me there. Perhaps you're remarkably perceptive because you know me so well. Or maybe you came to that conclusion because I admitted that it was "unreasonably nationalistic" in the original post. Because of course the residents of Turkey, they're NOT being nationalistic in their block voting. They've taken a reasonable, dispassionate look at the entirety of the globe and decided, realistically, that Istanbul is THE paragon of international cities. Right. That's why the United Nations HQ is there.

So what if Monopoly is American-made. It's worldwide now and other countries seem to like it more.

And since baseball is now international, let's relocate the World Series to Tokyo.

If New York isn't #1, it's because enough people don't care about it. THAT'S JUST HOW THINGS ARE.

NO IT'S NOT. It's entirely possible that, with a national election eating up the news cycles, the vast majority of Americans simply don't KNOW about it. So what I'm doing is trying to MAKE them aware and get things stirred up on the internet.

PAD

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 22, 2008 10:29 AM

I think this is good nationalism. In fact, I think this is *absolutely the best* nationalism.

Is this thread demanding that other countries act like us? Think like us? Change their government to be like ours? Nope, we're yelling, "Let's get 'em!" about a board game. That's about as harmful as rooting for your own country in the Olympics.

But if you really feel like we're doing something horrible, bruholland, just tell me what country you're from. I've got five cities left I can vote for, so I'll show you how horribly nationalistic I am by voting for one of yours, too.

Posted by: El hombre Malo at February 22, 2008 10:54 AM

Reasonable pride in one's country or home city justifies voting for it. I did.

But if someone asked me to vote for Valencia, Bilbao or Sevilla (all spanish cities, all over the million, all historically and artistically rich) I would have laughed. Because, in my book, London, Paris, NY, Honk Kong (and Instanbul, of course)... dozens of cities, are far more relevant. And because the more diverse the board, the more appealing the game, worlwide.

The sting of pride that makes you flood the voting site to get your city elected is fantastic. But when it turns into an effort not to get A city but as much as possible, just to be on Top, to get as many of the others out... when, thats ugly. Because its no longer a game of jumpingh higher, but a game of pushing the others out. And thats bad nationalism (is there any kind of good nationalism?)

Posted by: m at February 22, 2008 11:11 AM

is there any kind of good nationalism?

Reasonable pride in one's country

Posted by: Peter David at February 22, 2008 11:17 AM

Because, in my book, London, Paris, NY, Honk Kong (and Instanbul, of course)... dozens of cities, are far more relevant.

Yes, except...I voted for London. And Paris. And Hong Kong. And Madrid.

I will venture to guess that residents of those other countries dominating the voting did not return the favor.

So again, your point is?

PAD

Posted by: Jason M. Bryant at February 22, 2008 11:25 AM

"Because its no longer a game of jumpingh higher, but a game of pushing the others out. And thats bad nationalism (is there any kind of good nationalism?)"

It's the exact same game. In this case there is absolutely no difference between trying to do better and trying to put others in second place. A footrace is about running faster than the other guy, a a pie making competition is about trying to make a better pie than the other guy, and this race is about making your favorite cities do better than other cities.

The whole contest is "show your support." We're trying to show the most support for the cities we like and they're trying to show the most support for the cities they like. All sides are trying to be number 1 and all sides are trying to make everyone else *not* be number 1. That's just a contest, nothing more. Calling that "bad nationalism" without showing that it actually harms anyone is silly.

Posted by: Bill Myers at February 22, 2008 11:33 AM

El hombre Malo: "Because, in my book, London, Paris, NY, Honk Kong (and Instanbul, of course)... dozens of cities, are far more relevant."

Geez Louise, it's just Monopoly. It's not like anyone's voting for "Which City Should be Nuked Into Non-Existence."

Although if I wanted to market a game to Al Qaeda, that might not be a bad title.

Posted by: Rich Johnston at February 22, 2008 12:10 PM

Been to New York and Istanbul. Istanbul wins. Sorry.

Posted by: Rich Johnston at February 22, 2008 12:14 PM

The British version (rather, the London version) got punted round the Commonwealth. As a result it became the iconic worldwide version of the board game.

Posted by: Bill Myers at February 22, 2008 12:38 PM

Rich Johnston: "Been to New York and Istanbul. Istanbul wins. Sorry."

Well, I'm glad that's settled. Now all you need to do is weigh in on whether there's a God, and there'll be nothing left for anyone anywhere to disagree about.

Posted by: Peter J Poole at February 22, 2008 12:44 PM

Hmmm... OK, I'd have a tough time choosing between London and Edinburgh, but luckily I didn't need to.

Cardiff is actually a nice city these days. Mainly because they threw a shedload of money at it over the last decade, so if you don't mind the homecoming queen being surgically enhanced, it's a maybe.

BTW, PAD, FWIW (ugh, acronym headache!) I would have given a vote to San Francisco, but it appears not to have made the cut...

Cheers,
PJP

Posted by: Mike at February 22, 2008 12:45 PM

Well, you can't go by what Rich says about God, because God still owes him $50.

Posted by: Bill Myers at February 22, 2008 12:59 PM

Peter J. Poole:"...I would have given a vote to San Francisco..."

Having been to both cities, I'd agree that both are significant. But I'd have to say NYC is the more significant of the two. The U.N. Building, the New York Stock Exchange, Broadway... NYC just has more impact on the U.S. and the world.

On an emotional level, I prefer NYC. Yeah, NYC can be congested, noisy, foul... but to me it's also vibrant, electric, filled to the brim with the potential for anything to happen. It's diverse, it's dynamic, it's filled with obstacles and opportunities.

I'm saying: I love NYC. And I don't even live there. So I'm voting for NYC.

I mean, I like Rochester, N.Y., and am happy to live there, but let's face it: no one is going to vote for Rochester. Not even me.

Posted by: The StarWolf at February 22, 2008 01:44 PM

Haven't checked the complete list yet. Is Houston included? Then one could vote for the NYC/Madrid/Tokyo/Houston quartet of cities in the original ROLLERBALL movie.

Hey, there's probably far worse reasons to vote for a place.

As for Ottawa? Live there. Like it. But it's no Montreal when it comes to multiculturalism.

Posted by: J. Alexander at February 22, 2008 02:02 PM

Hmmm. Enid, Oklahoma should be on the list. I am sure that anybody who has ever visited or lived there would agree. :-)

Posted by: Bill Myers at February 22, 2008 02:13 PM

J. Alexander, I was about to mention Enid but you beat me to it.

No, really.

Posted by: J. Alexander at February 22, 2008 03:50 PM

Bill, I truly and absolutely believe you. Once you experience life in Enid, you are no longer afraid of death. :-)

Posted by: Bill at February 23, 2008 09:07 AM

I posted the story and link on my two sites.

I think it's wrong that only one company is allowed to manufacture the game Monopoly. -- Steven Wright

Posted by: Bruholland at February 24, 2008 02:39 AM

[i]Well, gee...you really got me there. Perhaps you're remarkably perceptive because you know me so well. Or maybe you came to that conclusion because I admitted that it was "unreasonably nationalistic" in the original post. Because of course the residents of Turkey, they're NOT being nationalistic in their block voting. They've taken a reasonable, dispassionate look at the entirety of the globe and decided, realistically, that Istanbul is THE paragon of international cities. Right. That's why the United Nations HQ is there. [/i]

But, as far as I know, they're not writing blog posts telling their fellow citizens that their country's city isn't getting the attention it deserves. Your nationalism strikes me as bitter.

Posted by: Bruholland at February 24, 2008 02:40 AM

Well, gee...you really got me there. Perhaps you're remarkably perceptive because you know me so well. Or maybe you came to that conclusion because I admitted that it was "unreasonably nationalistic" in the original post. Because of course the residents of Turkey, they're NOT being nationalistic in their block voting. They've taken a reasonable, dispassionate look at the entirety of the globe and decided, realistically, that Istanbul is THE paragon of international cities. Right. That's why the United Nations HQ is there.

But, as far as I know, they're not writing blog posts telling their fellow citizens that their country's city isn't getting the attention it deserves. Your nationalism strikes me as bitter.

Posted by: Peter David at February 24, 2008 08:46 AM

But, as far as I know, they're not writing blog posts telling their fellow citizens that their country's city isn't getting the attention it deserves. Your nationalism strikes me as bitter.

As far as you know. I see. And just how far DO you know? How many blogs of how many residents of Turkey have you actually surveyed? How much have you investigated the efforts of bloggers in Turkey to catapult Istanbul to the top? For that matter, are you fluent in Turkish?

My nationalism is at most, as I upfront admitted, unreasonable, and now I'm starting to think it wasn't even that. Your post, however, strikes me as stepped in ignorance and false assumptions, unless you can prove otherwise.

PAD

Posted by: Sean at February 24, 2008 10:16 AM

"Yeah, NYC can be congested, noisy, foul..."

Okay, even though there are literally a dozen different responses to that, most of which involve my family and how even with all that, I like 'em anyway, not going there. That could be said of ANY major city in the world. Get that many people living in a confined space, it's not going to be spic and span. Or quiet. But, for this case, and others I suppose, if you focus on the more positive aspects of NYC(the Met, Rockefeller Center, the UN, Broadway, the arts, the Village, the Mets, the Empire State Building, New York style pizza, egg creams, the list is endless-ish!)

I will, just so everyone knows it's actually me and not some fake, say that what would a blog in Turkey be like? "Not happy with the giblets today. The cranberries are giving major 'tude. Stuffing hit the floor, ROTFLMHO."

Great. Now I'm hungry.

Posted by: Bill Mulligan at February 24, 2008 11:40 AM

Your nationalism strikes me as bitter.

based on exactly what?

This has turned from an amusing little throwaway bit into an example of why many Americans find it hard to take many non-americans seriously. Is this really worth getting angry over? I mean really angry, not like what PAD posted.

Or to put it another way, I could easily, all too easily, see this actually making the news and having riots in some third world backwater over the perceived slight toward said backwater. "You have insulted the name of Butfukistan! Now you must die!"

Here, not so much. Better things to do.

Posted by: Bill Myers at February 24, 2008 12:59 PM

Sean: "...if you focus on the more positive aspects of NYC..."

In fairness, Sean, that's what I was doing. As I said, I really do love NYC, and I believe the positive aspects of the city by far outweight its flaws.

Bill Mulligan: "Is this really worth getting angry over?"

I hate you.

Posted by: Alan Coil at February 24, 2008 01:55 PM

Bruholland, I'm so sorry. It must really be uncomfortable.

Posted by: Kelly R Hoose at February 24, 2008 04:49 PM

Istanbul!


LOL I would vote for that, but didn't. How couold you not laugh at Istanbul, it's got that funny song too Istanbul from Constandanoble(or something) LOL

OMG! (that's so sad)

PS: does anyone even play that game anymore? I knew there are collector but I don't know anyone that plays it, anymore....

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 24, 2008 04:52 PM

Look Bruholland,

It’s a game. Not Monopoly mind you, the whole thing. It’s like rooting for your favorite football team. Everybody does it and everybody says that their team should win/be #1. And it’s not like we’re talking politics, war, major life and death issues or sharks with laser beams on their heads here. We’re talking about a fricking board game people. The competition is meant to be as fun as the game. It could be as well if certain types of people would learn to not get a bug up their backsides.

This entire thread is pretty much just the sports/team/competition mindset going on. It’s not that bad and it’s not just us Americans. Three minutes on Google gets you all of this and more. If you wanna complain here about us, go tell it to the posters in Turkey, Canada, England, Israel, India, South Africa, etc.


”Genel Forum --> monopoly world edition (vote for istanbul)”

www.dt-home.com/forum/cevaplar.asp?konuID=6792

“Istanbul nominated for global Monopoly”

www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=94787

“Vote for Montreal as a city in the new Monopoly game”

www.topix.com/forum/ca/montreal-qc/TPJE4232FTF3HJF3O

“World Monopoly - Vote for Singapore”

www.sgclub.com/singapore/world_monopoly_vote_47705.html

”Jerusalem on the Monopoly board”
”Please ONLY vote for Jerusalem.”

//bokertov.typepad.com/btb/2008/02/jerusalem-on-th.html

”Did you guys VOTE for INDIA yet?”

//in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080126091040AAuj98B

”Your country needs you: Historic rivalry reignited as France tries to sabotage our Monopoly board bid”

www.mailonsunday.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=516148&in_page_id=1770


Oh, and if you think we’re being bad…

”Hasbro pulls countries from Monopoly site after Israel flap”

www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2008-02-21-hasbro-countries_N.htm

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 24, 2008 04:54 PM

Look Bruholland,

It’s a game. Not Monopoly mind you, the whole thing. It’s like rooting for your favorite football team. Everybody does it and everybody says that their team should win/be #1. And it’s not like we’re talking politics, war, major life and death issues or sharks with laser beams on their heads here. We’re talking about a fricking board game people. The competition is meant to be as fun as the game. It could be as well if certain types of people would learn to not get a bug up their backsides.

This entire thread is pretty much just the sports/team/competition mindset going on. It’s not that bad and it’s not just us Americans. Three minutes on Google gets you all of this and more. If you wanna complain here about us, go tell it to the posters in Turkey, Canada, England, Israel, India, South Africa, etc.


”Genel Forum --> monopoly world edition (vote for istanbul)”

www.dt-home.com/forum/cevaplar.asp?konuID=6792

“Istanbul nominated for global Monopoly”

www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=94787

“Vote for Montreal as a city in the new Monopoly game”

www.topix.com/forum/ca/montreal-qc/TPJE4232FTF3HJF3O

“World Monopoly - Vote for Singapore”

www.sgclub.com/singapore/world_monopoly_vote_47705.html

”Jerusalem on the Monopoly board”
”Please ONLY vote for Jerusalem.”

//bokertov.typepad.com/btb/2008/02/jerusalem-on-th.html

”Did you guys VOTE for INDIA yet?”

//in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080126091040AAuj98B

”Your country needs you: Historic rivalry reignited as France tries to sabotage our Monopoly board bid”

www.mailonsunday.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=516148&in_page_id=1770


Oh, and if you think we’re being bad…

”Hasbro pulls countries from Monopoly site after Israel flap”

www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2008-02-21-hasbro-countries_N.htm

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 24, 2008 04:57 PM

Look Bruholland,

It’s a game. Not Monopoly mind you, the whole thing. It’s like rooting for your favorite football team. Everybody does it and everybody says that their team should win/be #1. And it’s not like we’re talking politics, war, major life and death issues or sharks with laser beams on their heads here. We’re talking about a fricking board game people. The competition is meant to be as fun as the game. It could be as well if certain types of people would learn to not get a bug up their backsides.

This entire thread is pretty much just the sports/team/competition mindset going on. It’s not that bad and it’s not just us Americans. Three minutes on Google gets you all of this and more. If you wanna complain here about us, go tell it to the posters in Turkey, Canada, England, Israel, India, South Africa, etc.

I had to cut a “w” off the fronts of the addresses because the post was catching in the filter due to the amount of links.


”Genel Forum --> monopoly world edition (vote for istanbul)”

ww.dt-home.com/forum/cevaplar.asp?konuID=6792

“Istanbul nominated for global Monopoly”

ww.turkishdailynews.com.tr/article.php?enewsid=94787

“Vote for Montreal as a city in the new Monopoly game”

ww.topix.com/forum/ca/montreal-qc/TPJE4232FTF3HJF3O

“World Monopoly - Vote for Singapore”

ww.sgclub.com/singapore/world_monopoly_vote_47705.html

”Jerusalem on the Monopoly board”
”Please ONLY vote for Jerusalem.”

//bokertov.typepad.com/btb/2008/02/jerusalem-on-th.html

”Did you guys VOTE for INDIA yet?”

//in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080126091040AAuj98B

”Your country needs you: Historic rivalry reignited as France tries to sabotage our Monopoly board bid”

ww.mailonsunday.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=516148&in_page_id=1770


Oh, and if you think we’re being bad…

”Hasbro pulls countries from Monopoly site after Israel flap”

ww.usatoday.com/news/nation/2008-02-21-hasbro-countries_N.htm

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 24, 2008 04:57 PM

Am I the only one getting snagged up with every post today?

Posted by: Jerry Chandler at February 24, 2008 05:15 PM

Bruholland,

There’s another post I made to you, but it’s being snagged in the filter due to the links I took from Google. First, this is basically just a big game. This is like rooting for your favorite sports team and doing the whole “rah-rah-rah” thing. We’re not here discussing something serious like war, death, politics or zombie films. It’s silly, goofy, fun gamesmanship over a game. And American’s aren’t the only ones.

Try doing a Google search on “monopoly "vote for Istanbul"” or “turkey monopoly vote for Istanbul” when you have a minute. You’ll get links of blogs and news site’s chat boards from Turkey, England, Canada, Japan, Israel, South Africa, etc. where people in each of those countries is doing exactly what’s being done here. And, unlike some here who are voting New York and then voting for some other non-American cities, you’ll find people instructing others to only vote for their cities.

And I’m not going to hold that against them. They’re playing the game and having fun just like we were. If you’d learn to lighten up a little, relax and not try to take offense to things like this, you’ll have more fun.

Now to a downer note:

The radio just announced that Ben Chapman passed away today. Chapman was a former Marine and, more importantly to geeks (like me) everywhere, he was chosen due to his 6’4/6’5 frame to be the Creature in all of the above water scenes in Creature from the Black Lagoon.

Posted by: Bill Mulligan at February 25, 2008 12:38 AM

Bummer about Ben Chapman--he did a great job, one of those iconic roles that will live forever.

Just got back an hour or so ago from Conoogah where I got to meet Mr. Chapman's physical opposite-- Felix Silla. Yeah! Got to meet the freaking Manitou!

Great great guy, btw. Really sweet and down to earth. One nice thing about these smaller cons is that the celebs who show up tend to be among the nicest-- Mr. Silla, Michael Berryman, Dee Wallace-Stone, the guy who walked into the helicopter propeller in DAWN OF THE DEAD...friendly folks all, not like certain stuck up superstars like Bill Shatner or the guy who gets hit in the head with a machete in DAWN OF THE DEAD.

(I kid. Leonard A. Lies (Machete Zombie)is a super nice guy.)

Posted by: AdamYJ at February 25, 2008 05:31 PM

Well, I'm from the US and New York State to boot, but I'm not sure if I would vote for New York City. Why? Because I just really don't care for NYC. It's kind of dirty and smelly and the city itself just feels kind of overwhelming to me. It has some good cultural institutions, but I don't like it much beyond that. I also harbor a grudge over the fact that everyone semms to think that New York City is the only New York there is. You go out of state and tell someone you're from New York, they automatically think you're from New York City. You tell someone from New York City that you're from Upstate and they roll their eyes and start talking to you like you just wandered off some dairy farm in the middle of nowhere (note, I live near Albany, which is itself an important city in that it's actually the seat of governmental power for the whole freakin' state).

I'd vote for Boston, though. I love Boston. I usually have a good time when I go to Boston and I could easily see myself living there.

Posted by: Kate at February 29, 2008 01:41 PM

People who have been writing very intelligent comments like "Istanbul, oh my goooooooood, are you kiddin' me?", have you ever taken any art history classes? or let me put it this way, have you ever taken anything in history? Read any books? nah? I thought so. Go at least on google and find out about the city. I have been there and it is definitely one of the best cities, for sure.

Posted by: Emre at March 1, 2008 05:56 AM

Hi,i'm from Turkey. And it's nice to see that while you have a competitive spirit about this,you don't insult us or belittle Turkey.I just wanted to thank you for that.

And it seems even after all those years,we can't shake off the "Midnight Express" effect.Even though author of the book admitted that a lot of things were exaggerated.We just need better propaganda,i guess.

Anyway,i just searched the relevant words like monopoly in Turkish using google and it seems lots of people in Turkey are voting for this and write about it in blogs.

PS:Correct me if i'm wrong but: wasn't there 2 Ataturks in Time Magazine's voting? One at first spot and the other in #8.

Posted by: zxevil160 at March 12, 2008 11:20 PM

tx6Pto U cool ))